Editors . . . are people?

After last week’s post detailing some of the disappointments editors and agents face, I received several intriguing comments. And of course, it got me thinking (as these things often do) about the underlying concept swirling through all of them.

There are tons of blog posts and articles and exposés and even books about life from both sides of the publishing fence, but much like I pointed out last week, there’s still this sense of divide, this lack of empathy, this disconnect in perception — regarding publishing professionals especially. Now maybe that’s simply because there are more authors than editors in the world, or maybe it’s just that they’re more vocal about the less glamorous sides of publishing than the rest of us. But more likely, it’s the shroud publishing has kept so tightly wrapped around itself that has perpetuated this myth, this idea that editors and agents are mythical, deadly beings who deign to walk among the masses only so they can destroy fragile author egos and feast on their pain.

Don’t believe me? Stop for a moment and try this: clear your mind and, without any sort of precursor, think the word “editor.”

What image pops to mind? Did you see a person, or did you simply see the title, the word itself, floating in your imagination like some incorporeal stamp. Or, worse, did you see some sort of deranged monster hanging out in the back of the editing cave looking like this:


Regardless of what you saw, I can almost guarantee that you didn’t truly picture a person. No one does. More often than not, the word “editor” is synonymous with a concept, a perception, and everyone’s idea is slightly different, sort of like this:


Notice that final photo — that’s what it really looks like, kids. Because, contrary to what we’ve all been told, editors (and agents) are human. We’re not cyborgs or demons. We’re people stuffed full of emotions, and dreams, and expectations, and flaws. We’re not infallible; we make mistakes. We’re not pre-programmed with all the infinite wisdom of generations of literary masters, we don’t have built-in grammar bibles or the latest in spell-check software hardwired into our brains, and we’re not static. We learn, we grow, we hope, we dream.

And yes, the process of editing does often look like this for us too:

Editing Meme

And yet, the myth endures. Interesting, isn’t it? How easily we throw aside the idea of human compassion when it’s only words on a screen staring at you. How easily we cast aside the thought of the person behind the comments and see only our wounded egos. How easily we direct our rage and hurt at the person/people who are actually our allies.

I’m not saying that the editing process isn’t painful — it often is. I’m not even trying to make this a PSA-type plea for empathy. I’m merely musing on this strange sort of limbo publishing professionals are relegated to — a land where the reality of deadlines, and mountains of paperwork, and the necessities of life are brushed under the rug of perception until they don’t exist. Until everyone assumes that editors live in this sort of perpetual state of editing, that we only creep out of the ether to work, subsisting on nothing but the words before us.

So, I guess the point I’m trying to make is this — yes, editors and agents are people.

And really, we’re just trying to save you from the pain of this:


Maybe it’s time to we let the misconceptions fade and remember that we’re all human — whether we’re an author, an agent, an editor, or any of the other countless jobs that go into producing the books we love so much. Maybe it’s time to let the shroud of mystery fall and send the ghosts and ghouls, demons and monsters back into the shadows where they belong. Maybe it’s time to put the humanity back into our interactions and stop letting labels, titles, words stand between us.


5 thoughts on “Editors . . . are people?

  1. LOVED the Book Editor collage, wonderful. When I thought of ‘editor’ at your prompt, I pictured a lady at her desk with my book open, and an incredulous look :”She thought THIS was ready?”

    • Hahaha, well at least you pictured a person. That’s more generous than some I’ve heard. 😉

      I’m glad you enjoyed the post though, and thanks for taking the time to read and comment! ❤

  2. The more editors I work with the more excited I become for the process. I sort of look at it this way…

    If I’m walking down 5th Avenue with a friend, taking them to my favorite coffee shop that they have never been to, we will both notice our surroundings differently. If they have never been on my route and it is one I walk with frequency, I may mosey along in a very habitual manner. I know when to cross the busy street and which short cuts to take. I may know the light at Madison is excruciatingly long, but it’s worth taking to avoid the flyer pushers on the corner of 43rd. I’ll travel with sure steps and confident maneuvering, consequentially paying little attention to things I’ve passed on a regular basis.

    Now, if my friend is new to the area or just doesn’t walk it as often as I do, they are going to be more open to paying attention. They don’t have to worry about when to cross the street or where, because they are following my lead. So, they can be open to notice the little details and nuances that I may have missed. Perhaps they are even reminded of something they saw the last time they were in the area, and they will point out something new. It’s not that they are ignorant of how to walk in a busy metropolis like New York, their radars are just tuned to a different frequency in that moment. They may even pull me back from the road when I’m about to step into traffic because I’m more focused on getting us to our destination with thoughts like…”Avenue of the Americas is 6th street, right? Dammit, I can never remember!”

    To me, the writer/editor relationship is very similar. I know where I’m going in my writing, because I’ve been to this coffee shop daily. I know all the baristas, the regulars, and the occasional drop ins. I have my favorite chair and table in the corner, worn smooth by the oils of many hands and the fabrics of many derrieres. And I will probably order my favorite drink and scone. Fortunately, my editor friend has fresh eyes to see things that I’d miss because I’ve become a bit jaded to my environment. They’ll point out the new things on the menu, the cute guy who apparently stares at me every time I come in, and the pretty necklace the girl behind the counter is wearing. The place suddenly becomes new and wondrous in that moment, just from their observations and guidance. In the end, who guided who, really?

    Sorry, that was a long winding analogy…huh? See, Kisa…I need you to edit my jumbled thoughts. Haha!

    • It may be a tad long, but it’s an excellent analogy. I think you’re spot on with it. Though, you do kind of have an advantage, having worked on both sides of the publishing fence yourself. Gives you a more realistic picture of the relationship than I think a lot of authors (especially new authors) have the luxury of. 😉

      That said, thank you for taking the time to write such an eloquent response! ❤

Have Comments? Please leave them here! :)

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s